Seoul High Court Upholds Cancellation of Saemangeum International Airport Basic Plan
South Korea’s Seoul High Court has upheld a ruling to cancel the government’s basic plan for the Saemangeum International Airport, finding that authorities failed to adequately evaluate aviation safety and environmental risks. The decision marks a significant victory for citizen groups opposing the project on the Sura Mudflat.
The Seoul High Court has upheld a lower court’s decision to cancel the government’s Basic Plan for the Saemangeum International Airport, ruling that the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport failed to properly assess aviation safety risks and environmental consequences during the planning phase.
On October 18, the Administrative Division 4-2 of the Seoul High Court, presided over by Judge Lee Kwang-man, delivered its second-instance verdict in a lawsuit filed by three citizens belonging to the Saemangeum New Airport Cancellation Joint Action. The court affirmed the September 11 ruling from the Seoul Administrative Court, which had initially ordered the cancellation of the development plan.
In its judgment, the appellate panel determined that the ministry had prioritized economic development benefits without sufficiently weighing the public interest in protecting life, bodily safety, and the environment. "The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport assigned superior weight to development benefits without examining, to a degree commensurate with their importance, the public interest in the protection of life and bodily safety and in environmental conservation," the court stated. "Because the plan is unlawful, it must be canceled."
The proposed Saemangeum International Airport project aims to construct a runway, apron, passenger terminal, and cargo terminal on a 3.4 million square meter site within the Saemangeum area of North Jeolla Special Self-Governing Province. The government had targeted a completion date of 2028 for the facility.
The planned construction site, known as the Sura Mudflat, is a critical habitat for approximately 240,000 migratory birds, including 59 endangered species such as spoonbills and various shorebirds. This ecological significance has drawn strong opposition from environmental organizations and local residents since the lawsuit was filed in September 2022.
The court’s decision heavily criticized the ministry’s approach to aviation safety, specifically regarding the risk of bird strikes. The panel noted that the ministry had not considered bird-strike risks at all during the initial site-selection stage. "Rather than first selecting a site and then retrospectively reviewing ways to manage the risk, the Ministry should have examined from the site-selection stage whether bird-strike risk could be avoided or sufficiently reduced," the ruling explained.
The court further observed that even mitigation measures presented later by the ministry were insufficient given the site's specific characteristics. The Sura Mudflat lies on major migratory routes and is surrounded by numerous wintering grounds and stopover sites for migratory birds, creating inherent safety challenges that the government had not adequately addressed.
During the proceedings, the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport argued that the airport was necessary to promote balanced regional development. The court acknowledged the strong desire among North Jeolla residents and businesspeople to boost the region's economic vitality but rejected the argument that this justified proceeding with an unsafe plan. "Such public interest presupposes that the airport can be operated safely," the panel emphasized. It added that aviation safety is a public interest that must be given particular weight when selecting an airport site because "a single bird-strike accident can cause grave harm to many lives, bodies, and property."
The courtroom was filled with activists and citizens from the Joint Action and environmental groups awaiting the verdict. As Judge Lee read the order stating that the plan must be canceled due to a defect in the balancing of interests, applause and cheers erupted from the gallery. Attendees clapped one another’s hands, shouted "We won," and some hugged each other in tears.
Attorney Choi Jae-hong, who represented the plaintiffs, addressed the media following the ruling. "The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport spoke of the importance of science and technology, but the countless lives that visit the Saemangeum mudflats have prevailed," he said. "I believe the wishes of citizens who hope that a second Muan Airport disaster will not occur and that the Sura Mudflat will not disappear moved the court."
The reference to the Muan Airport disaster alludes to a previous incident involving bird strikes at South Korea’s Muan International Airport, highlighting the plaintiffs' concerns about potential safety failures in new aviation projects.
With the appellate ruling now finalizing the cancellation of the basic plan, the future of the Saemangeum airport project remains uncertain. The government must now reassess its infrastructure strategies in the region, potentially seeking alternative sites that do not conflict with critical migratory bird habitats or pose unacceptable safety risks.
(O.Robinson--TAG)